This is what stocks my gift closet every year, right here. I thought they weren't going to have the under $5 list this year, but here it is! All of these items are a good discount, not just dollar store toys. I love looking through here, and they are constantly adding new items.
SO...check it out here, the UNDER $5 Toy list.
Angry birds plushes are mostly $2.99, there are Winx dolls, Thomas the Train items, American Girl, Monster High, and many other popular toy items and brands. Check out the list for yourself, but here are a few good ones that I can see:
If you are looking for a deal in the $6-10 range, don't forget those under $10 links. They still have great items, and the 70% off page is also awesome.
Remember that prices go up and down pretty quickly sometimes. If you
see something at the price you like, you'll need to get it quickly.